Direct Investing vs Fund Allocation: A Decision Framework for Family Offices
Direct investing has accelerated since 2020. It also fails quietly more often than the headlines suggest. This is how to tell when direct makes sense.
Key takeaways
- —Direct investing requires deal flow, due-diligence depth, and post-investment governance — all three, not two of three.
- —Co-investment alongside committed funds captures most of the upside without the operational drag.
- —The hidden cost of direct is usually the talent: senior investment staff cost more than two layers of fund fees on a portfolio under $200M.
- —A clean exit policy matters more than the entry thesis.
The post-2020 shift toward direct investing among family offices is real but uneven. Some offices have built genuine direct-investment capability; many more have a portfolio of one-off positions that look like a programme on paper. The difference is operational, not philosophical.
The three-question test
Before committing to a direct programme, answer three questions honestly. Do you see at least 100 quality opportunities a year through proprietary channels? Can you fund a senior team that can do real diligence — not just review GP materials? Have you defined how a portfolio company is governed once owned, including reporting cadence, board composition, and intervention triggers? If any answer is uncertain, direct is the wrong frame.
Co-investment as the middle path
For many offices, co-investment alongside committed fund managers captures most of the structural appeal of direct — economic exposure, control over check size, fee compression — without the operational burden. Negotiate co-invest rights into fund commitments; few GPs will refuse a serious anchor LP.
The honest exit question is harder than the entry question. A direct portfolio without a written exit policy — held duration, distribution mechanics, valuation discipline — is illiquid by accident, not by design. Families that survive direct programmes are the ones that wrote the exit policy first.
Stay informed
Weekly insights for family office professionals.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.